KDET to KARB Flight Report - Piper PA-24-250 Comanche

Flight from KDET to KARB

Saturday, 16 March 2024 11:17

Minutes 30

42 nm

Fuel 13 kg

Piper PA-24-250 Comanche

Departure

Runway 33 at KDET

Coleman A Young Muni

Detroit, Michigan, United States

Altitude

623 ft asl

Weight

1,057 kg

Fuel

108 kg

Temperature

4 °C

Wind Speed

7 kt

Wind Direction

190.0 °

Headwind

-5 kt

Crosswind

5 kt

Arrival

Runway 06 at KARB

Ann Arbor Mun

Ann Arbor Michigan, United States

827 ft asl

Altitude

1,044 kg

Weight

95 kg

Fuel

-1 °C

Temperature

6 kt

Wind Speed

200.0 °

Wind Direction

-5 kt

Headwind

3 kt

Crosswind

Flight Score 91.40%

Departure Score 93.98%

Enroute Score 94.64%

Arrival Score 83.22%

Vertical profile — planned vs actual

Landing

59.46 %

Touchdown

97.73 %

Warning: Landed with a 5 kt tailwind

Approach & flare

Threshold height

38.56 %

Good threshold height.

Threshold speed

89.81 %

Threshold speed was a little below target at 59 kt.

Flare

9.71 %

Very poor landing flare

Touchdown

Sink rate

96.39 %

Touchdown rate was excellent at -86 ft/m.

Impact

72.57 %

Speed

100 %

Touchdown speed at 49 kt was good.

Aim point

100 %

Touchdown distance was good at 206 m.

Centreline

100 %

Runway touchdown alignment was perfect.

Bounce

100 %

Flight Map

Replay this flight in 3D — the full flight path over the terrain with every stage, event and score along the route.

Flight Stages KDET to KARB

Click on a stage to view more detailed information

Departure Taxi

100 %

Taxiing from the parking to the runway took 3 minutes and covered less than 1 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average speed 12 kn 0 kn min to max 20 kn	0		6 kn
100 %	Average speed turning corners 13 kn max 16 kn	0		0 kn
100 %	Average g force 1.01 g 0.89 g min to max 1.11 g	0.99		0.99 g
100 %	Beacon, navigation and taxi lights on
Info	Average pitch angle 3.7 ° 2.8 ° min to max 4.2 °	3.2		3.4 °
Info	Average bank angle 0.2 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.5 °	0.0		0.1 °
Info	Battery Master On at 11:17:28
Info	Engine 1 Started at 11:17:28
Info	Beacon Lights Switched On at 11:17:28
Info	Landing Gear Down at 11:17:28
Info	Parking Brake On at 11:17:28
Info	Landing Lights Switched On at 11:17:37
Info	Taxi Lights Switched On at 11:17:38
Info	Navigation Lights Switched On at 11:17:39
Info	Parking Brake Off at 11:18:22
Info	Parking Brake On at 11:18:36
Info	Parking Brake Off at 11:19:39

Departure Roll

84.91 %

Departure roll runway 33 at KDET Coleman A Young Muni. Takeoff distance 1,259 m 81 % of runway. Liftoff speed was 70 kn. Local weather - Temperature 4 °C. Wind 7 kn at 190 °. Crosswind: 5 kn Tailwind: 5 kn.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
75.11 %	Takeoff distance 1,259 m 81 % of runway
100 %	Liftoff speed was 70 kn Target 70 kn
94.28 %	Runway alignment max 4.62 m 4.62 m left to 0.00 m left	2.08		4.62 m
60.57 %	Average g force 0.49 g 0.06 g min to max 1.00 g	1.00		0.06 g
100 %	Takeoff Bounce
Info	Average pitch angle 3.1 ° 2.7 ° min to max 4.0 °	3.6		3.6 °
Info	Average bank angle 0.7 ° 0.0 ° min to max 2.1 °	0.1		1.0 °
Info	Parking Brake On at 11:20:55
Info	Strobe Lights Switched On at 11:22:24
Info	Parking Brake Off at 11:22:55
Info	Taxi Light ON should OFF at 11:23:08

Departure Climb 1

96 %

Departure climb to 50 ft agl from runway 33 KDET Coleman A Young Muni.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Heading variation -0.8 ° -1.0 ° min to max -0.7 °	-1.0		-0.7 °
100 %	Average speed 80 kn 70 kn min to max 85 kn	70		85 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 0.4 ° 0.0 ° min to max 1.2 °	0.8		1.2 °
60 %	Average g force 0.96 g 0.05 g min to max 1.15 g	0.05		1.10 g
Info	Average VSI 490 ft/m 294 ft/m min to max 784 ft/m	294		784 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 16 ft agl 0 ft agl min to max 46 ft agl	0		46 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle 5.9 ° 3.6 ° min to max 9.3 °	3.6		9.3 °

Departure Climb 2

97.01 %

Departure climb to 400 ft agl from 33 KDET Coleman A Young Muni.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Heading variation -0.5 ° -0.7 ° min to max 0.7 °	-0.7		0.7 °
100 %	Average speed 85 kn 84 kn min to max 88 kn	85		88 kn
97.66 %	Average bank angle 1.6 ° 0.2 ° min to max 2.9 °	1.3		1.1 °
76 %	Average g force 0.98 g 0.33 g min to max 1.11 g	1.08		0.33 g
Info	Average VSI 1,117 ft/m 802 ft/m min to max 1,419 ft/m	802		1,068 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 112 ft agl 47 ft agl min to max 364 ft agl	47		364 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle 10.4 ° 8.1 ° min to max 11.6 °	9.4		8.4 °
Info	Landing Gear Up at 11:23:21

Departure Climb 3

91.98 %

Departure climb to 1,000 ft agl from 33 KDET Coleman A Young Muni.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Heading variation 1.5 ° 0.7 ° min to max 3.2 °	0.7		3.2 °
100 %	Average speed 93 kn 90 kn min to max 94 kn	91		91 kn
71.03 %	Average bank angle 6.3 ° 0.3 ° min to max 13.0 °	0.3		13.0 °
77.71 %	Average g force 0.80 g 0.36 g min to max 0.86 g	0.84		0.74 g
100 %	Landing gear up
Info	Average VSI 1,552 ft/m 1,163 ft/m min to max 1,823 ft/m	1,163		1,660 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 591 ft agl 403 ft agl min to max 802 ft agl	403		802 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle 11.0 ° 8.7 ° min to max 12.6 °	8.7		11.6 °

Enroute Climb

90.66 %

Enroute climb started overhead KDET Coleman A Young Muni Detroit (Michigan, United States). Climbing from 1,457 ft asl to 6,165 ft asl, an increase of 4,709 ft in 6 minutes and covering 6 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average speed 103 kn 88 kn min to max 142 kn	90		100 kn
83.8 %	Average bank angle 15.0 ° 0.1 ° min to max 48.1 °	13.9		0.8 °
71.43 %	Average g force 0.85 g 0.25 g min to max 1.48 g	0.78		0.51 g
Info	Average VSI 752 ft/m 127 ft/m min to max 1,649 ft/m	1,649		768 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 2,856 ft asl 1,457 ft asl min to max 6,165 ft asl	1,457		6,165 ft asl
Info	Average pitch angle 5.4 ° 1.4 ° min to max 11.4 °	11.4		3.3 °
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0
Info	Taxi Lights Switched Off at 11:26:31
Info	Strobe Lights Switched Off at 11:26:32

Enroute Level

98.8 %

Enroute level cruise started 2 miles south west of Highland Park (Michigan, United States) and lasted 12 minutes, covering 28 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average altitude 6,139 ft asl 6,114 ft asl min to max 6,170 ft asl	6,155		6,136 ft asl
100 %	Average speed 148 kn 111 kn min to max 153 kn	111		151 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 0.4 ° 0.0 ° min to max 2.9 °	0.0		0.1 °
88 %	Average g force 0.77 g 0.54 g min to max 1.07 g	0.83		0.75 g
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0
Info	Average pitch angle -0.7 ° -2.9 ° min to max 5.0 °	0.6		-0.8 °
Info	Landing Lights Switched Off at 11:40:03
Info	Landing Lights Switched On at 11:40:04
Info	Landing Lights Switched Off at 11:40:06

Enroute Descent

94.46 %

Enroute descent started 1 mile south west of Ann Arbor (Michigan, United States). Descent from 5,942 ft asl to 2,654 ft asl, a decrease of 3,288 ft in 3 minutes and covering 4 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average speed 117 kn 76 kn min to max 151 kn	151		76 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 14.2 ° 0.3 ° min to max 28.9 °	0.7		25.8 °
44.57 %	Average g force 0.77 g -0.22 g min to max 1.06 g	-0.22		0.77 g
Info	Average VSI -1,413 ft/m -4,095 ft/m min to max 153 ft/m	-4,095		-1,635 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 4,317 ft asl 2,654 ft asl min to max 5,942 ft asl	5,942		2,654 ft asl
Info	Average pitch angle -5.7 ° -20.8 ° min to max -0.3 °	-20.8		-2.1 °
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0
Info	Landing Lights Switched On at 11:43:28
Info	Landing Gear Down at 11:44:23
Info	Flaps Position 3 at 11:44:38
Info	Flaps Position 6 at 11:44:40
Info	Flaps Position 9 at 11:44:43

Arrival

97.38 %

Arrival started 1 mile south west of Ann Arbor (Michigan, United States).

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average speed 73 kn 58 kn min to max 84 kn	75		82 kn
97.44 %	Average bank angle 13.1 ° 0.6 ° min to max 32.5 °	25.4		11.2 °
92 %	Average g force 0.82 g 0.61 g min to max 1.19 g	0.78		1.19 g
Info	Average VSI -1,363 ft/m -1,730 ft/m min to max -869 ft/m	-1,641		-1,334 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 2,004 ft asl 1,400 ft asl min to max 2,627 ft asl	2,627		1,400 ft asl
Info	Average pitch angle -5.3 ° -9.0 ° min to max 4.0 °	-2.7		-2.7 °
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0

Arrival Final 1

74.28 %

Approaching runway 06 at KARB Ann Arbor Mun from 1 nm to 0 nm. Descent from 557 ft agl to 22 ft agl. A decrease of 535 ft in 35 seconds.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
2.91 %	Approach angle 2.8 ° 1.4 ° min to max 5.5 ° Target 3.0 °	5.4		1.4 °
100 %	Average speed 61 kn 58 kn min to max 80 kn	80		59 kn
93.2 %	Heading variation -0.1 ° -0.6 ° min to max 0.7 °	0.6		0.1 °
78.14 %	Average bank angle 2.6 ° 0.0 ° min to max 11.2 °	9.3		1.8 °
94.29 %	Average g force 0.94 g 0.65 g min to max 1.29 g	0.90		0.94 g
Info	Average VSI -715 ft/m -1,272 ft/m min to max -396 ft/m	-996		-666 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 110 ft agl 22 ft agl min to max 557 ft agl	557		22 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle -2.0 ° -8.1 ° min to max 2.3 °	-2.7		-0.1 °

Arrival Landing

59.46 %

Landing on runway 06 at KARB Ann Arbor Mun, runway length 1,051 m. Good threshold height. Threshold speed was a little below target at 59 kn.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
89.81 %	Threshold speed was a little below target at 59 kn. Target 70 kn
38.56 %	Target 50 ft agl
9.71 %	Landing and flare profile
100 %	Heading variation 0.0 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.1 °	0.1		0.0 °
100 %	Average bank angle 0.8 ° 0.0 ° min to max 1.8 °	1.8		0.2 °
98.86 %	Average g force 0.85 g 0.73 g min to max 1.05 g	0.91		0.81 g
Info	Average speed 54 kn 49 kn min to max 59 kn	59		49 kn
Info	Average VSI -263 ft/m -665 ft/m min to max -67 ft/m	-665		-84 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 5 ft agl 0 ft agl min to max 17 ft agl	17		0 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle 3.1 ° 0.5 ° min to max 4.9 °	0.5		3.8 °

Arrival Touchdown

97.73 %

Touchdown distance was good at 206 m. Touchdown speed at 49 kn was good. Touchdown rate was excellent at -84 ft/m. Runway touchdown alignment was perfect. Local weather - Temperature -1 °C. Wind 6 kn at 200 °. Crosswind: 3 kn Tailwind: 5 kn.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
96.39 %	Touchdown VSI was -84 ft/m.
100 %	Touchdown distance was 206 m Target 457 m
100 %	Speed at touchdown 49 kn Target 55 kn
100 %	Runway alignment max 0.54 m 0.23 m right	0.02		-0.52 m
100 %	Average bank angle 0.8 ° 0.1 ° min to max 1.3 °	0.2		1.3 °
72.57 %	Average g force 0.54 g 0.27 g min to max 0.82 g	0.81		0.27 g
100 %	Landing Bounce
Info	Average speed 49 kn 48 kn min to max 49 kn	49		48 kn
Info	Average pitch angle 4.4 ° 3.8 ° min to max 5.2 °	3.8		5.2 °

Arrival Rollout

94.65 %

Total landing distance 455 m, 43 % of runway. Runway rollout alignment was very good.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Landing distance 455 m 43 % of runway.
96.76 %	Runway alignment max 4.14 m 0.20 m left to 3.94 m right	-0.59		0.05 m
61.14 %	Average g force 0.25 g 0.07 g min to max 0.73 g	0.23		0.73 g
Info	Average speed 56 kn 33 kn min to max 60 kn	60		33 kn
Info	Average pitch angle 3.7 ° 2.4 ° min to max 5.2 °	5.2		2.6 °
Info	Average bank angle 1.1 ° 0.0 ° min to max 1.9 °	1.4		0.3 °

Runway Exit

Exiting runway, average speed 1 kn

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
Info	Average speed 15 kn 9 kn min to max 26 kn	26		17 kn
Info	Average pitch angle 3.5 ° 2.2 ° min to max 4.1 °	2.2		3.8 °
Info	Average bank angle 0.3 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.7 °	0.0		0.2 °
Info	Average g force 0.99 g 0.85 g min to max 1.11 g	0.88		1.03 g
Info	Flaps Position 6 at 11:47:10
Info	Flaps Position 3 at 11:47:11
Info	Flaps Fully Retracted at 11:47:12

Arrival Taxi

90 %

Taxiing to the parking from the runway took 1 minutes and covered less than 1 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average speed 12 kn 5 kn min to max 19 kn	17		6 kn
100 %	Average speed turning corners 11 kn max 15 kn	0		0 kn
100 %	Average g force 1.04 g 0.92 g min to max 1.18 g	1.00		0.94 g
Info	Average pitch angle 3.6 ° 2.7 ° min to max 4.0 °	3.5		3.7 °
Info	Average bank angle 0.2 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.7 °	0.2		0.1 °
Info	Parking Brake On at 11:47:51
Info	Landing Lights ON should be OFF at 11:47:24
Info	Taxi Light OFF should be ON at 11:47:29
Info	Engine 1 Stopped at 11:47:58
Info	Navigation Lights Switched Off at 11:48:00
Info	Landing Lights Switched Off at 11:48:02
Info	Beacon Lights Switched Off at 11:48:05

Takeoff on runway 33 at KDET Coleman A Young Muni in the Piper PA-24-250 Comanche

93.98 %

100 %

Taxi

Taxiing from the parking to the runway took 3 minutes and covered less than 1 nm.

Taxi Lights

100 %

Switched On

Ground Speed kt

100 %

Turn Speed

100 %

Bank °

Info

Pitch °

Info

84.91 %

Takeoff Roll

Takeoff Distance

100 %

Roll distance of 1,259 m using 81.22 % of runway

Liftoff Speed

100 %

Liftoff speed was 70 kn - Target 70 kn

Alignment

94.28 %

4.62 m left to 0.00 m left

Bounce

100 %

No Bounce Detected

Strobe Lights

100 %

Switched On

Landing Lights

100 %

Switched On

60.57 %

IAS kt

Info

Bank °

Info

Pitch °

Info

96 %

Climb 1

Departure climb to 50 ft agl from runway 33 KDET Coleman A Young Muni.

Alignment

100 %

IAS kt

100 %

Bank °

100 %

60 %

Pitch °

Info

Climb Rate fpm

Info

97.01 %

Climb 2

Departure climb to 400 ft agl from 33 KDET Coleman A Young Muni.

Alignment

100 %

IAS kt

100 %

Bank °

97.66 %

76 %

Pitch °

Info

Climb Rate fpm

Info

91.98 %

Climb 3

Departure climb to 1,000 ft agl from 33 KDET Coleman A Young Muni.

Alignment

100 %

IAS kt

100 %

Bank °

71.03 %

77.71 %

Pitch °

Info

Climb Rate fpm

Info

Landing on runway 06 at KARB Ann Arbor Mun in the Piper PA-24-250 Comanche

Landing Score 81.53 %

74.28 %

Final 1

Approaching runway 06 at KARB Ann Arbor Mun from 1 nm to 0 nm. Descent from 557 ft agl to 22 ft agl. A decrease of 535 ft in 35 seconds.

Glideslope

2.91 %

Poor descent path above glideslope limit

Heading

93.2 %

Great heading alignment

Glideslope °

2.91 %

IAS kt

100 %

Alignment

93.2 %

Bank °

78.14 %

94.29 %

Descent Rate fpm

Info

59.46 %

Landing

Landing on runway 06 at KARB Ann Arbor Mun, runway length 1,051 m. Good threshold height. Threshold speed was a little below target at 59 kn.

Height

38.56 %

Good threshold height. Target 50 ft agl

Speed

89.81 %

Threshold speed was a little below target at 59 kt. Target 70 kt

Flare

9.71 %

Very poor landing flare

Centreline ft

100 %

Bank °

100 %

98.86 %

IAS kt

Info

Pitch °

Info

Descent Rate fpm

Info

97.73 %

Touchdown

96.39 %

Touchdown rate was excellent at -86 ft/m.

Speed

100 %

Touchdown speed at 49 kt was good. Target below 55 kn

Distance

100 %

Touchdown distance was good at 206 m.

Alignment

100 %

Runway touchdown alignment was perfect.

Bank

100 %

Bank angle 0.8 °

72.57 %

G 0.54 g

Bounce

100 %

No Bounce Detected

94.65 %

Rollout

Total landing distance 455 m, 43 % of runway. Runway rollout alignment was very good.

Distance

100 %

Landing distance 455 m using 43.29 % of runway

Alignment

96.76 %

Runway rollout alignment was very good.

61.14 %

IAS kt

Info

Bank °

Info

Pitch °

Info

90 %

Taxi

Taxiing to the parking from the runway took 1 minutes and covered less than 1 nm.

Landing Lights

-2 %

Switched On

Taxi Lights

-2 %

Switched Off

Ground Speed kt

100 %

Turn Speed

100 %

Bank °

Info

Pitch °

Info

Metrics

Scroll or drag the slider to zoom · double-click to reset · hover for values

More Flights Like This

KDET → KDET

Coleman A. Young Municipal Airport to Coleman A. Young Municipal Airport

Cirrus SR22

05 Dec 2025 · 10 nm 95.09%

KDET → KMTC

Coleman A. Young Municipal Airport to Selfridge Air National Guard Base Airport

PA28 Warrior II

01 Dec 2025 · 20 nm 94.89%

LFRC → LFRC

Cherbourg-Maupertus Airport to Cherbourg-Maupertus Airport

Piper PA-24 Comanche

25 Aug 2026 · 10 nm 92.85%

KPAE → 61WA

Seattle Paine Field International Airport to Burden Field-(Rabbit Run) Airport

Piper PA-24 Comanche

23 Aug 2026 · 57 nm 77.45%

More flights at KDET · More flights at KARB · More Piper PA-24-250 Comanche flights · Browse all flights