EDYK to EDFB Flight Report - Piper PA-24-250 Comanche

Flight from EDYK to EDFB

Tuesday, 20 August 2024 14:25

Minutes 27

46 nm

Fuel 16 kg

Piper PA-24-250 Comanche

Departure

Runway 27 at EDYK

Siegen-Eisernhardt Airfield

Siegen, Nordrhein-Westfalen, Germany

Altitude

1,280 ft asl

Weight

996 kg

Fuel

131 kg

Temperature

20 °C

Wind Speed

11 kt

Wind Direction

186.8 °

Headwind

0 kt

Crosswind

10 kt

Arrival

Runway 18 at EDFB

Reichelsheim

Reichelsheim Hessen, Germany

397 ft asl

Altitude

979 kg

Weight

115 kg

Fuel

24 °C

Temperature

4 kt

Wind Speed

144.7 °

Wind Direction

4 kt

Headwind

2 kt

Crosswind

Flight Score 95.73%

Departure Score 92.75%

Enroute Score 99.71%

Arrival Score 93.40%

Flight Map

Replay this flight in 3D — the full flight path over the terrain with every stage, event and score along the route.

Flight Stages EDYK to EDFB

Click on a stage to view more detailed information

Departure Runway Entry

Entering runway 27 at EDYK Siegen-Eisernhardt Airfield, Average speed was 0 kn.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
Info	Average speed 10 kn 0 kn min to max 18 kn	0		8 kn
Info	Average pitch angle 3.9 ° 3.0 ° min to max 4.4 °	4.4		3.3 °
Info	Average bank angle 0.2 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.7 °	0.0		0.2 °
Info	Average g force 0.97 g 0.79 g min to max 1.16 g	1.00		0.96 g
Info	Battery Master On at 14:25:52
Info	Engine 1 Started at 14:25:52
Info	Beacon Lights Switched On at 14:25:52
Info	Navigation Lights Switched On at 14:25:52
Info	Strobe Lights Switched On at 14:25:52
Info	Landing Gear Down at 14:25:52

Departure Roll

89.81 %

Departure roll runway 27 at EDYK Siegen-Eisernhardt Airfield. Takeoff distance 296 m 40 % of runway. Liftoff speed was 69 kn. Local weather - Temperature 20 °C. Wind 11 kn at 186 °. Crosswind: 11 kn Headwind: 0 kn.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Takeoff distance 296 m 40 % of runway
100 %	Liftoff speed was 69 kn Target 70 kn
80.89 %	Runway alignment max 11.63 m 8.29 m left to 3.34 m right	-2.95		8.03 m
86.29 %	Average g force 0.40 g 0.02 g min to max 0.99 g	0.99		0.02 g
100 %	Takeoff Bounce
Info	Average pitch angle 3.0 ° 2.0 ° min to max 3.6 °	2.5		2.7 °
Info	Average bank angle 1.7 ° 0.0 ° min to max 5.6 °	0.3		5.6 °
0 %	Landing Lights at 14:32:14

Departure Climb 1

94.93 %

Departure climb to 50 ft agl from runway 27 EDYK Siegen-Eisernhardt Airfield.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
98.11 %	Heading variation -0.4 ° -1.2 ° min to max 0.1 °	-1.2		0.0 °
100 %	Average speed 79 kn 70 kn min to max 84 kn	70		83 kn
87.21 %	Average bank angle 4.7 ° 0.1 ° min to max 6.9 °	5.5		3.6 °
86 %	Average g force 0.95 g 0.01 g min to max 1.06 g	0.01		0.95 g
Info	Average VSI 512 ft/m 315 ft/m min to max 668 ft/m	315		668 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 13 ft agl 0 ft agl min to max 40 ft agl	0		40 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle 5.7 ° 2.7 ° min to max 8.0 °	2.7		8.0 °

Departure Climb 2

93.52 %

Departure climb to 400 ft agl from 27 EDYK Siegen-Eisernhardt Airfield.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
98.38 %	Heading variation -0.3 ° -2.1 ° min to max 0.0 °	0.0		-2.1 °
100 %	Average speed 84 kn 80 kn min to max 90 kn	83		90 kn
76.5 %	Average bank angle 1.4 ° 0.0 ° min to max 10.9 °	3.1		10.9 °
98 %	Average g force 0.92 g 0.43 g min to max 1.01 g	0.94		0.96 g
Info	Average VSI 876 ft/m 666 ft/m min to max 1,228 ft/m	677		1,228 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 96 ft agl 41 ft agl min to max 350 ft agl	41		350 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle 9.0 ° 7.8 ° min to max 10.4 °	8.1		8.6 °
Info	Landing Gear Up at 14:33:15

Enroute Climb

100 %

Enroute climb started overhead EDYK Siegen-Eisernhardt Airfield Siegen (Nordrhein-Westfalen, Germany). Climbing from 1,656 ft asl to 4,643 ft asl, an increase of 2,987 ft in 3 minutes and covering 6 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average speed 106 kn 87 kn min to max 137 kn	91		137 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 8.8 ° 0.3 ° min to max 28.9 °	13.0		0.3 °
100 %	Average g force 0.92 g 0.79 g min to max 1.04 g	0.94		0.84 g
Info	Average VSI 977 ft/m -363 ft/m min to max 1,776 ft/m	1,319		-363 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 3,005 ft asl 1,656 ft asl min to max 4,643 ft asl	1,656		4,643 ft asl
Info	Average pitch angle 5.8 ° -2.5 ° min to max 11.7 °	8.6		-2.5 °
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0

Enroute Level

100 %

Enroute level cruise started 2 miles north east of Burbach (Nordrhein-Westfalen, Germany) and lasted 1 minutes, covering 3 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average altitude 4,630 ft asl 4,572 ft asl min to max 4,715 ft asl	4,596		4,638 ft asl
100 %	Average speed 143 kn 136 kn min to max 150 kn	142		137 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 9.5 ° 0.3 ° min to max 18.5 °	8.5		10.0 °
100 %	Average g force 0.91 g 0.67 g min to max 1.01 g	0.88		0.95 g
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0
Info	Average pitch angle -1.8 ° -4.0 ° min to max 1.6 °	-2.4		-1.8 °

Enroute Descent

100 %

Enroute descent started 1 mile west of Haiger (Hessen, Germany). Descent from 4,613 ft asl to 4,102 ft asl, a decrease of 511 ft in 1 minutes and covering 3 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average speed 138 kn 132 kn min to max 146 kn	138		132 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 4.4 ° 0.6 ° min to max 10.7 °	6.7		1.3 °
100 %	Average g force 0.89 g 0.63 g min to max 1.26 g	0.83		0.94 g
Info	Average VSI -487 ft/m -1,148 ft/m min to max 210 ft/m	-441		-439 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 4,311 ft asl 4,102 ft asl min to max 4,613 ft asl	4,613		4,102 ft asl
Info	Average pitch angle -2.5 ° -4.9 ° min to max -0.0 °	-3.3		-1.8 °
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0

Enroute Level 2

98.57 %

Enroute level cruise started 2 miles north east of Breitscheid (Hessen, Germany) and lasted 13 minutes, covering 27 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average altitude 3,881 ft asl 3,542 ft asl min to max 4,114 ft asl	4,057		3,593 ft asl
100 %	Average speed 124 kn 115 kn min to max 134 kn	132		126 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 7.5 ° 0.0 ° min to max 19.8 °	6.9		8.2 °
85.71 %	Average g force 0.89 g 0.00 g min to max 1.19 g	0.92		0.88 g
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0
Info	Average pitch angle -0.6 ° -3.1 ° min to max 6.4 °	-0.4		-0.7 °

Enroute Descent 2

100 %

Enroute descent started 1 mile east of Muenzenberg (Hessen, Germany). Descent from 3,592 ft asl to 2,258 ft asl, a decrease of 1,334 ft in 2 minutes and covering 4 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average speed 127 kn 120 kn min to max 132 kn	125		121 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 7.4 ° 0.3 ° min to max 16.4 °	8.7		0.3 °
100 %	Average g force 0.91 g 0.64 g min to max 1.09 g	0.94		0.92 g
Info	Average VSI -686 ft/m -1,487 ft/m min to max 150 ft/m	-52		-883 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 2,847 ft asl 2,258 ft asl min to max 3,592 ft asl	3,592		2,258 ft asl
Info	Average pitch angle -3.7 ° -6.2 ° min to max -0.2 °	-0.9		-4.0 °
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0

Arrival

100 %

Arrival started 1 mile east of Muenzenberg (Hessen, Germany).

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average speed 95 kn 75 kn min to max 122 kn	121		76 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 1.7 ° 0.0 ° min to max 5.9 °	2.4		0.3 °
100 %	Average g force 0.90 g 0.70 g min to max 1.07 g	0.92		0.96 g
Info	Average VSI -726 ft/m -1,215 ft/m min to max -381 ft/m	-866		-1,034 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 1,564 ft asl 858 ft asl min to max 2,244 ft asl	2,244		858 ft asl
Info	Average pitch angle -2.9 ° -5.3 ° min to max -1.3 °	-4.1		-4.7 °
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0
Info	Landing Gear Down at 14:55:40
Info	Flaps Position 3 at 14:56:20

Arrival Final 1

83.53 %

Approaching runway 18 at EDFB Reichelsheim from 1 nm to 0 nm. Descent from 444 ft agl to 41 ft agl. A decrease of 403 ft in 24 seconds.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
20.79 %	Approach angle 3.7 ° 2.3 ° min to max 6.0 ° Target 3.0 °	6.0		2.3 °
100 %	Average speed 71 kn 70 kn min to max 76 kn	75		70 kn
100 %	Heading variation 0.2 ° 0.2 ° min to max 0.3 °	0.3		0.2 °
100 %	Average bank angle 0.5 ° 0.0 ° min to max 1.7 °	0.1		0.5 °
93.71 %	Average g force 0.94 g 0.28 g min to max 1.07 g	0.85		0.86 g
Info	Average VSI -947 ft/m -1,209 ft/m min to max -823 ft/m	-1,002		-823 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 125 ft agl 41 ft agl min to max 444 ft agl	444		41 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle -3.0 ° -5.2 ° min to max -1.1 °	-5.2		-1.6 °

Arrival Landing

99.08 %

Landing on runway 18 at EDFB Reichelsheim, runway length 1,230 m. Good threshold height. Threshold speed was good at 70 kn.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Threshold speed was good at 70 kn. Target 70 kn
100 %	Target 50 ft agl
96.33 %	Landing and flare profile
100 %	Heading variation 0.2 ° 0.2 ° min to max 0.2 °	0.2		0.2 °
100 %	Average bank angle 0.9 ° 0.0 ° min to max 1.8 °	0.5		0.3 °
100 %	Average g force 0.94 g 0.83 g min to max 1.09 g	0.88		0.94 g
Info	Average speed 62 kn 53 kn min to max 70 kn	70		54 kn
Info	Average VSI -314 ft/m -817 ft/m min to max -83 ft/m	-817		-142 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 10 ft agl 0 ft agl min to max 33 ft agl	33		0 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle 3.3 ° -1.6 ° min to max 5.3 °	-1.6		5.1 °

Arrival Touchdown

96.14 %

Touchdown distance was good at 289 m. Touchdown speed at 54 kn was good. Touchdown rate was smooth at -142 ft/m. Runway touchdown position was slightly misaligned by 3.4 m from centreline. Local weather - Temperature 24 °C. Wind 4 kn at 144 °. Crosswind: 2 kn Headwind: 4 kn.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
98.56 %	Touchdown VSI was -142 ft/m.
100 %	Touchdown distance was 289 m Target 457 m
100 %	Speed at touchdown 54 kn Target 55 kn
98.56 %	Runway alignment max 3.44 m 3.37 m left	3.35		3.44 m
100 %	Average bank angle 0.6 ° 0.3 ° min to max 0.9 °	0.3		0.9 °
94.29 %	Average g force 0.64 g 0.30 g min to max 0.95 g	0.94		0.30 g
80 %	Landing Bounce
Info	Average speed 53 kn 51 kn min to max 54 kn	54		51 kn
Info	Average pitch angle 5.9 ° 5.1 ° min to max 6.7 °	5.1		6.7 °

Arrival Rollout

94.84 %

Total landing distance 517 m, 42 % of runway. Runway rollout alignment was very good.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Landing distance 517 m 42 % of runway.
90.76 %	Runway alignment max 5.58 m 5.58 m left to 0.00 m left	3.45		1.79 m
90 %	Average g force 0.48 g 0.15 g min to max 0.86 g	0.27		0.74 g
Info	Average speed 52 kn 33 kn min to max 56 kn	56		33 kn
Info	Average pitch angle 3.7 ° 1.7 ° min to max 6.7 °	6.7		1.7 °
Info	Average bank angle 0.6 ° 0.0 ° min to max 1.4 °	0.9		0.2 °

Runway Exit

Exiting runway, average speed 6 kn

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
Info	Average speed 11 kn 0 kn min to max 28 kn	28		0 kn
Info	Average pitch angle 1.8 ° 0.9 ° min to max 2.6 °	1.8		2.6 °
Info	Average bank angle 0.1 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.2 °	0.0		0.1 °
Info	Average g force 1.02 g 0.78 g min to max 1.18 g	0.78		1.17 g
Info	Parking Brake On at 14:57:37

Takeoff on runway 27 at EDYK Siegen-Eisernhardt Airfield in the Piper PA-24-250 Comanche

92.75 %

89.81 %

Takeoff Roll

Takeoff Distance

100 %

Roll distance of 296 m using 40.48 % of runway

Liftoff Speed

100 %

Liftoff speed was 69 kn - Target 70 kn

Alignment

80.89 %

8.29 m left to 3.34 m right

Bounce

100 %

No Bounce Detected

Strobe Lights

100 %

Switched On

Landing Lights

0 %

Switched On

86.29 %

Speed

Info

Bank

Info

Pitch

Info

94.93 %

Climb 1

Departure climb to 50 ft agl from runway 27 EDYK Siegen-Eisernhardt Airfield.

Heading

98.11 %

Speed

100 %

Bank

87.21 %

86 %

Pitch

Info

Climb Rate

Info

93.52 %

Climb 2

Departure climb to 400 ft agl from 27 EDYK Siegen-Eisernhardt Airfield.

Heading

98.38 %

Speed

100 %

Bank

76.5 %

98 %

Pitch

Info

Climb Rate

Info

Landing on runway 18 at EDFB Reichelsheim in the Piper PA-24-250 Comanche

Landing Score 93.4 %

Landing Summary

Great job on achieving a landing score of 93.4%! Let's break down the different phases of the landing to see where improvements can be made.

During the Approach Phase, there was a poor descent path above the glideslope limit. It is important to maintain a stable descent path to ensure a smooth landing. It would be beneficial to pay closer attention to the descent path and make adjustments as needed to stay within the glideslope limit.

Moving on to the Landing Phase, there were positive elements such as a good threshold height and an excellent landing flare. These aspects show good control and skill during the final moments before touchdown.

In the Touchdown Phase, the touchdown rate was smooth and the speed was on target. Additionally, the touchdown distance was inside the touchdown zone, which is crucial for a safe and precise landing. However, the runway touchdown position was 3.4 m from the centerline, indicating a slight deviation from the ideal landing spot.

Lastly, during the Rollout Phase, the runway alignment was 5.6 m from the centerline. This shows room for improvement in maintaining straight alignment upon landing.

Overall, your landing performance was strong, with notable areas of achievement in the Landing and Touchdown Phases. Focus on improving the descent path during the Approach Phase and ensuring precise alignment in the Rollout Phase to continue to enhance your skills as a pilot. Keep up the good work and continue striving for excellence in every phase of the landing process.

83.53 %

Final 1

Approaching runway 18 at EDFB Reichelsheim from 1 nm to 0 nm. Descent from 444 ft agl to 41 ft agl. A decrease of 403 ft in 24 seconds.

Glideslope

20.79 %

Poor descent path above glideslope limit

Heading

100 %

Great heading alignment

Glideslope

20.79 %

IAS