Track every flight, analyse your performance,
and master your flying skills with My FS Flights
Get 10 flights free every month!
Tracked and analysed flights over miles
The flight on the A321 began at KBOI Boise Air Terminal/Gowen Field, where the aircraft taxied 2 nm from parking to runway 28R. The departure roll on the runway was 1,988 meters, with the aircraft reaching a liftoff speed of 162 knots. The local weather at departure included a temperature of 22 °C, with a wind of 16 knots at 10°, resulting in a crosswind of 15 knots and a headwind of 4 knots.
Once airborne, the enroute climb began 1 mile west of KBOI, with the aircraft climbing from 3,880 ft asl to 35,131 ft asl over a distance of 149 nm. The climb lasted approximately 13 minutes. The enroute level cruise phase started 17 miles southwest of 4U9 Dell Flight Strip in Dell, Montana, and lasted for 47 minutes over a distance of 721 nm.
The enroute descent phase commenced 4 miles southwest of Minneota in Minnesota, with the aircraft descending from 35,726 ft asl to 2,721 ft asl over a distance of 119 nm. The descent lasted around 15 minutes. The landing took place on runway 12R at KMSP Minneapolis-St Paul Intl, with the aircraft touching down 507 m from the threshold at a speed of 138 knots. The total landing distance was 1,590 m, accounting for 52% of the runway length. The local weather at arrival included a temperature of 30 °C, with a wind of 12 knots at 139°, resulting in a crosswind of 4 knots and a headwind of 11 knots.
After landing, the aircraft taxied to parking in less than 1 nm, taking 2 minutes. The total flight distance covered was 999 nm, with a duration of 87 minutes. The flight consumed 6,972 kg of fuel during the journey.
Replay this flight in 3D — the full flight path over the terrain with every stage, event and score along the route.
Taxiing from the parking to the runway took 7 minutes and covered 2 nm.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 93.33 % |
Average speed 17 kn 0 kn min to max 26 kn |
3 | 17 kn | |
| 91.25 % |
Average speed turning corners 15 kn max 18 kn |
0 | 17 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.00 g 0.98 g min to max 1.02 g |
0.98 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 0.1 ° -0.4 ° min to max 0.6 ° |
-0.1 | 0.2 ° | |
| Info |
Average bank angle 0.2 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.7 ° |
0.3 | 0.3 ° | |
| Info |
Battery Master On at 13:23:51 |
|||
| Info |
Engine 2 Started at 13:23:51 |
|||
| Info |
Beacon Lights Switched On at 13:23:51 |
|||
| Info |
Navigation Lights Switched On at 13:23:51 |
|||
| Info |
Landing Gear Down at 13:23:51 |
|||
| Info |
Parking Brake On at 13:24:24 |
|||
| Info |
Engine 1 Started at 13:25:16 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 2 at 13:26:35 |
|||
| Info |
Parking Brake Off at 13:26:39 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 3 at 13:26:43 |
|||
| Info |
Taxi Lights Switched On at 13:27:17 |
|||
| Info |
Strobe Lights Switched On at 13:30:40 |
Entering runway 28R at KBOI Boise Air Terminal\/Gowen Fld, Average speed was 6 kn.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| Info |
Average speed 15 kn 13 kn min to max 16 kn |
16 | 13 kn | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 0.1 ° -0.2 ° min to max 0.3 ° |
0.2 | -0.2 ° | |
| Info |
Average bank angle 0.3 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.5 ° |
0.2 | 0.2 ° | |
| Info |
Average g force 1.00 g 0.99 g min to max 1.01 g |
1.01 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Landing Lights Switched On at 13:30:44 |
Departure roll runway 28R at KBOI Boise Air Terminal\/Gowen Fld. Takeoff distance 1,988 m 66 % of runway. Liftoff speed was 162 kn. Local weather - Temperature 22 °C. Wind 16 kn at 10 °. Crosswind: 15 kn Headwind: 4 kn.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Takeoff distance 1,988 m 66 % of runway |
|||
| 100 % |
Liftoff speed was 162 kn Target 160 kn |
|||
| 31.91 % |
Runway alignment max 27.79 m 6.06 m left to 21.73 m right |
6.06 | -21.73 m | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.00 g 0.91 g min to max 1.08 g |
1.00 | 0.97 g | |
| 100 % |
Takeoff Bounce |
|||
| Info |
Average pitch angle -0.2 ° -0.8 ° min to max 2.8 ° |
-0.2 | 2.7 ° | |
| Info |
Average bank angle 0.4 ° 0.0 ° min to max 1.4 ° |
0.3 | 0.7 ° |
Departure climb to 50 ft agl from runway 28R KBOI Boise Air Terminal\/Gowen Fld.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Heading variation 0.6 ° 0.5 ° min to max 0.6 ° |
0.6 | 0.5 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 166 kn 162 kn min to max 167 kn |
162 | 167 kn | |
| 98.89 % |
Average bank angle 1.4 ° 0.4 ° min to max 2.4 ° |
0.8 | 2.4 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.10 g 0.79 g min to max 1.41 g |
0.97 | 1.04 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI 532 ft/m 88 ft/m min to max 781 ft/m |
88 | 781 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 5 ft agl -4 ft agl min to max 28 ft agl |
0 | 28 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 6.4 ° 0.7 ° min to max 11.5 ° |
2.6 | 11.1 ° |
Departure climb to 400 ft agl from 28R KBOI Boise Air Terminal\/Gowen Fld.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Heading variation 0.4 ° 0.1 ° min to max 0.5 ° |
0.5 | 0.1 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 168 kn 165 kn min to max 169 kn |
167 | 165 kn | |
| 85.11 % |
Average bank angle 1.5 ° 0.0 ° min to max 7.7 ° |
2.4 | 0.0 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.24 g 1.04 g min to max 1.37 g |
1.08 | 1.04 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI 1,410 ft/m 796 ft/m min to max 3,216 ft/m |
796 | 3,216 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 77 ft agl 29 ft agl min to max 323 ft agl |
29 | 323 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 15.2 ° 11.7 ° min to max 16.3 ° |
11.7 | 16.0 ° | |
| Info |
Taxi Lights Switched Off at 13:31:56 |
|||
| Info |
Landing Gear Up at 13:31:56 |
Departure climb to 1,000 ft agl from 28R KBOI Boise Air Terminal\/Gowen Fld.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Heading variation -0.3 ° -0.6 ° min to max -0.1 ° |
-0.1 | -0.6 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 167 kn 165 kn min to max 171 kn |
166 | 168 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.6 ° 0.1 ° min to max 1.3 ° |
0.9 | 0.8 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 0.98 g 0.96 g min to max 1.00 g |
0.97 | 0.98 g | |
| 100 % |
Landing gear up |
|||
| Info |
Average VSI 3,491 ft/m 3,418 ft/m min to max 3,552 ft/m |
3,418 | 3,549 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 700 ft agl 438 ft agl min to max 965 ft agl |
438 | 965 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 16.0 ° 15.9 ° min to max 16.1 ° |
15.9 | 16.0 ° |
Enroute climb started 1 mile west of KBOI Boise Air Terminal\/Gowen Fld Boise (Idaho, United States). Climbing from 3,880 ft asl to 35,131 ft asl, an increase of 31,250 ft in 13 minutes and covering 149 nm.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Average speed 251 kn 151 kn min to max 301 kn |
164 | 262 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 10.7 ° 0.0 ° min to max 30.3 ° |
0.6 | 0.0 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.03 g 0.74 g min to max 1.18 g |
0.95 | 0.98 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI 1,549 ft/m 364 ft/m min to max 3,541 ft/m |
3,540 | 364 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 14,357 ft asl 3,880 ft asl min to max 35,131 ft asl |
3,880 | 35,131 ft asl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 6.3 ° 2.7 ° min to max 16.0 ° |
16.0 | 3.5 ° | |
| Info |
Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0 |
0 | 0 | |
| Info |
Flaps Position 2 at 13:33:11 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 1 at 13:33:52 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Fully Retracted at 13:34:22 |
|||
| Info |
Landing Lights Switched Off at 13:35:36 |
Enroute level cruise started 17 miles south west of 4U9 Dell Flight Strip Dell (Montana, United States) and lasted 47 minutes, covering 721 nm.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Average altitude 35,515 ft asl 35,114 ft asl min to max 35,735 ft asl |
35,163 | 35,726 ft asl | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 261 kn 249 kn min to max 264 kn |
261 | 261 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.6 ° 0.0 ° min to max 17.6 ° |
0.2 | 0.1 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.00 g 0.83 g min to max 1.13 g |
1.00 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0 |
0 | 0 | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 3.3 ° 0.5 ° min to max 5.4 ° |
3.3 | 3.1 ° |
Enroute descent started 4 miles south west of Minneota (Minnesota, United States). Descent from 35,726 ft asl to 2,721 ft asl, a decrease of 33,005 ft in 15 minutes and covering 119 nm.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Average speed 237 kn 158 kn min to max 271 kn |
261 | 161 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 8.4 ° 0.0 ° min to max 20.3 ° |
1.7 | 0.0 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.02 g 0.90 g min to max 1.12 g |
1.00 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI -1,389 ft/m -2,490 ft/m min to max 21 ft/m |
-5 | -1,278 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 14,555 ft asl 2,721 ft asl min to max 35,729 ft asl |
35,726 | 2,721 ft asl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 0.7 ° -2.2 ° min to max 4.6 ° |
3.1 | -2.2 ° | |
| Info |
Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0 |
0 | 0 | |
| Info |
Landing Lights Switched On at 14:42:50 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 1 at 14:45:24 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 2 at 14:46:22 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 3 at 14:46:31 |
|||
| Info |
Landing Gear Down at 14:47:12 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 4 at 14:47:12 |
Arrival started 4 miles south west of Minneota (Minnesota, United States).
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Average speed 160 kn 155 kn min to max 163 kn |
161 | 155 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.1 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.3 ° |
0.1 | 0.3 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.01 g 0.91 g min to max 1.07 g |
1.00 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI -1,233 ft/m -1,730 ft/m min to max -701 ft/m |
-1,297 | -701 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 2,389 ft asl 2,135 ft asl min to max 2,698 ft asl |
2,698 | 2,135 ft asl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle -1.8 ° -4.2 ° min to max 0.2 ° |
-2.3 | 0.2 ° | |
| Info |
Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0 |
0 | 0 | |
| Info |
Flaps Position 5 at 14:48:25 |
Approaching runway 12R at KMSP Minneapolis-St Paul Intl from 4 nm to 3 nm. Descent from 1,294 ft agl to 914 ft agl. A decrease of 380 ft in 23 seconds.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Approach angle 3.0 ° 2.9 ° min to max 3.1 ° Target 3.0 ° |
3.1 | 2.9 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 148 kn 144 kn min to max 156 kn |
156 | 145 kn | |
| 100 % |
Heading variation -0.3 ° -0.4 ° min to max -0.2 ° |
-0.2 | -0.4 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.4 ° 0.0 ° min to max 1.0 ° |
0.1 | 0.3 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 0.99 g 0.97 g min to max 1.02 g |
1.00 | 1.01 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI -927 ft/m -1,057 ft/m min to max -693 ft/m |
-693 | -1,056 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 1,120 ft agl 914 ft agl min to max 1,294 ft agl |
1,294 | 914 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 0.5 ° -0.0 ° min to max 1.0 ° |
0.2 | 0.6 ° |
Approaching runway 12R at KMSP Minneapolis-St Paul Intl from 3 nm to 2 nm. Descent from 896 ft agl to 604 ft agl. A decrease of 293 ft in 24 seconds.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Approach angle 2.9 ° 2.8 ° min to max 2.9 ° Target 3.0 ° |
2.9 | 2.9 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 147 kn 145 kn min to max 150 kn |
145 | 150 kn | |
| 100 % |
Heading variation -0.4 ° -0.4 ° min to max -0.2 ° |
-0.4 | -0.2 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.9 ° 0.2 ° min to max 2.6 ° |
0.2 | 0.2 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.01 g 0.93 g min to max 1.05 g |
0.99 | 1.01 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI -756 ft/m -1,051 ft/m min to max -540 ft/m |
-1,051 | -695 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 771 ft agl 604 ft agl min to max 896 ft agl |
896 | 604 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 1.6 ° 0.6 ° min to max 2.3 ° |
0.6 | 1.8 ° |
Approaching runway 12R at KMSP Minneapolis-St Paul Intl from 2 nm to 1 nm. Descent from 592 ft agl to 292 ft agl. A decrease of 300 ft in 24 seconds.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Approach angle 2.9 ° 2.9 ° min to max 3.0 ° Target 3.0 ° |
2.9 | 2.9 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 151 kn 149 kn min to max 153 kn |
150 | 152 kn | |
| 100 % |
Heading variation -0.1 ° -0.2 ° min to max -0.1 ° |
-0.2 | -0.2 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.4 ° 0.2 ° min to max 1.3 ° |
0.2 | 0.2 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.00 g 0.97 g min to max 1.02 g |
1.00 | 1.01 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI -715 ft/m -886 ft/m min to max -614 ft/m |
-678 | -886 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 442 ft agl 292 ft agl min to max 592 ft agl |
592 | 292 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 1.5 ° 0.6 ° min to max 2.1 ° |
1.7 | 1.1 ° |
Approaching runway 12R at KMSP Minneapolis-St Paul Intl from 1 nm to 0 nm. Descent from 278 ft agl to 26 ft agl. A decrease of 252 ft in 19 seconds.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Approach angle 2.6 ° 2.3 ° min to max 2.9 ° Target 3.0 ° |
2.9 | 2.3 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 147 kn 145 kn min to max 151 kn |
151 | 146 kn | |
| 100 % |
Heading variation -0.1 ° -0.2 ° min to max 0.0 ° |
-0.1 | 0.0 ° | |
| 99.74 % |
Average bank angle 0.4 ° 0.1 ° min to max 3.4 ° |
0.4 | 0.4 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.00 g 0.91 g min to max 1.12 g |
1.02 | 1.12 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI -736 ft/m -875 ft/m min to max -611 ft/m |
-875 | -758 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 76 ft agl 26 ft agl min to max 278 ft agl |
278 | 26 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 1.2 ° -0.1 ° min to max 2.8 ° |
1.0 | 2.8 ° |
Landing on runway 12R at KMSP Minneapolis-St Paul Intl, runway length 3,040 m. Good threshold height. Threshold speed was good at 146 kn.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Threshold speed was good at 146 kn. Target 140 kn |
|||
| 100 % |
Target 50 ft agl |
|||
| 92.8 % |
Landing and flare profile |
|||
| 100 % |
Heading variation 0.1 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.2 ° |
0.0 | 0.2 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.4 ° 0.3 ° min to max 0.4 ° |
0.4 | 0.4 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.03 g 0.94 g min to max 1.14 g |
1.12 | 1.04 g | |
| Info |
Average speed 143 kn 137 kn min to max 147 kn |
146 | 138 kn | |
| Info |
Average VSI -308 ft/m -740 ft/m min to max -148 ft/m |
-740 | -264 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 12 ft agl -2 ft agl min to max 27 ft agl |
27 | -2 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 2.9 ° 2.1 ° min to max 3.7 ° |
2.9 | 3.1 ° |
Touchdown point was 82 m beyond the touchdown zone. Touchdown speed at 138 kn was good. Touchdown rate was fair at -264 ft/m. Runway touchdown position was misaligned by 11.9 m from centreline. Local weather - Temperature 30 °C. Wind 12 kn at 139 °. Crosswind: 4 kn Headwind: 11 kn.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 94.36 % |
Touchdown VSI was -264 ft/m. |
|||
| 94.5 % |
Touchdown distance was 507 m Target 457 m |
|||
| 100 % |
Speed at touchdown 138 kn Target 142 kn |
|||
| 67.86 % |
Runway alignment max 11.87 m 11.51 m left |
11.13 | 11.87 m | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.4 ° 0.3 ° min to max 0.4 ° |
0.4 | 0.4 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.12 g 1.04 g min to max 1.17 g |
1.04 | 1.14 g | |
| 100 % |
Landing Bounce |
|||
| Info |
Average speed 138 kn 138 kn min to max 138 kn |
138 | 138 kn | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 3.0 ° 2.9 ° min to max 3.1 ° |
3.1 | 2.9 ° |
Total landing distance 1,590 m, 52 % of runway. Runway rollout alignment was slightly misaligned by 13.8 m from centreline.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Landing distance 1,590 m 52 % of runway. |
|||
| 60.81 % |
Runway alignment max 23.24 m 13.80 m left to 9.44 m right |
12.10 | -5.61 m | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.02 g 0.97 g min to max 1.08 g |
1.08 | 0.98 g | |
| Info |
Average speed 119 kn 69 kn min to max 132 kn |
132 | 69 kn | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 1.7 ° -0.4 ° min to max 2.9 ° |
2.9 | -0.2 ° | |
| Info |
Average bank angle 0.4 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.6 ° |
0.4 | 0.0 ° |
Exiting runway, average speed 45 kn
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| Info |
Average speed 38 kn 25 kn min to max 65 kn |
65 | 25 kn | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle -0.0 ° -0.4 ° min to max 0.2 ° |
-0.2 | -0.1 ° | |
| Info |
Average bank angle 0.2 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.4 ° |
0.1 | 0.2 ° | |
| Info |
Average g force 1.00 g 0.99 g min to max 1.02 g |
1.00 | 0.99 g | |
| Info |
Strobe Lights Switched Off at 14:50:50 |
|||
| Info |
Taxi Lights Switched On at 14:50:53 |
|||
| Info |
Landing Lights Switched Off at 14:50:55 |
Taxiing to the parking from the runway took 2 minutes and covered less than 1 nm.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Average speed 13 kn 4 kn min to max 25 kn |
25 | 5 kn | |
| 77.5 % |
Average speed turning corners 12 kn max 19 kn |
0 | 0 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.00 g 0.99 g min to max 1.00 g |
1.00 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle -0.1 ° -0.5 ° min to max 0.0 ° |
-0.1 | -0.1 ° | |
| Info |
Average bank angle 0.1 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.6 ° |
0.3 | 0.0 ° | |
| Info |
Flaps Position 4 at 14:51:12 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 3 at 14:51:16 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 2 at 14:51:23 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 1 at 14:51:26 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Fully Retracted at 14:51:35 |
|||
| Info |
Taxi Lights Switched Off at 14:52:15 |
|||
| 100 % |
Taxi Lights at 14:51:40 |
|||
| Info |
Parking Brake On at 14:52:45 |
|||
| Info |
Engine 1 Stopped at 14:52:48 |
|||
| Info |
Engine 2 Stopped at 14:52:48 |
|||
| Info |
Beacon Lights Switched Off at 14:52:51 |
|||
| Info |
Beacon Lights Switched On at 14:52:52 |
Great job on achieving a landing score of 93.4%! Let's break down your performance in each phase of the aircraft landing to see what you did well and where you could possibly make some improvements.
Firstly, let's talk about the Approach Phase. You had excellent glideslope alignment, which indicates that your descent towards the runway was smooth and steady. This is a crucial aspect of the landing process as it sets the tone for a successful touchdown.
Moving on to the Landing Phase, you had a good threshold height, which means that you were at the right altitude as you crossed the runway threshold. Additionally, your landing flare was great, showing that you were able to transition smoothly from descent to landing. These are both key factors in ensuring a safe and controlled touchdown.
In the Touchdown Phase, your touchdown rate was firm, which is generally a positive thing as it indicates a decisive and controlled landing. Your speed was on target, which is crucial for a smooth touchdown. However, it's worth noting that the touchdown point was 82 meters beyond the touchdown zone. This indicates that you may have touched down further down the runway than desired. Additionally, the runway touchdown position was 11.9 meters from the centerline, which could be improved for better alignment.
Lastly, in the Rollout Phase, the runway alignment was 13.8 meters from the centerline. This shows a slight deviation from the ideal centerline alignment, which could be worked on for better precision in your landings.
Overall, you should be proud of your performance and the high landing score you achieved. Keep up the good work on maintaining excellent glideslope alignment, smooth threshold height, and controlled touchdown rate. Focus on improving your touchdown point and runway alignment for even better landings in the future. Your dedication and attention to detail will surely lead to continued success in your aviation endeavors. Great job!
Drag to zoom · double-click to reset · hover for values