EDTF to EDTF Flight Report - Piper PA-24-250 Comanche

Flight from EDTF to EDTF

Friday, 06 September 2024 13:50

Minutes 10

15 nm

Fuel 6 kg

Piper PA-24-250 Comanche

Departure

Runway 16 at EDTF

Freiburg\/Breisgau

Freiburg\/Breisgau, Baden-Wuerttemberg, Germany

Altitude

797 ft asl

Weight

979 kg

Fuel

115 kg

Temperature

21 °C

Wind Speed

1 kt

Wind Direction

248.2 °

Headwind

0 kt

Crosswind

0 kt

Arrival

Runway 16 at EDTF

Freiburg\/Breisgau

Freiburg\/Breisgau Baden-Wuerttemberg, Germany

797 ft asl

Altitude

973 kg

Weight

108 kg

Fuel

21 °C

Temperature

1 kt

Wind Speed

41.9 °

Wind Direction

0 kt

Headwind

0 kt

Crosswind

Flight Score 95.60%

Departure Score 90.52%

Enroute Score 100.00%

Arrival Score 95.33%

Vertical profile — planned vs actual

Landing

100 %

Touchdown

98.67 %

Approach & flare

Threshold height

100 %

Good threshold height.

Threshold speed

100 %

Threshold speed was slightly below target at 66 kt.

Flare

100 %

Perfect landing flare

Touchdown

Sink rate

96.93 %

Touchdown rate was good at -189 ft/m.

Impact

95.71 %

Speed

100 %

Touchdown speed at 58 kt was a little fast.

Aim point

100 %

Touchdown distance was good at 140 m.

Centreline

97.64 %

Runway touchdown position was slightly misaligned by 3.7 m from centreline.

Bounce

100 %

Flight Map

Replay this flight in 3D — the full flight path over the terrain with every stage, event and score along the route.

Flight Stages EDTF to EDTF

Click on a stage to view more detailed information

Departure Roll

90.78 %

Departure roll runway 16 at EDTF Freiburg\/Breisgau. Takeoff distance 359 m 40 % of runway. Liftoff speed was 68 kn. Local weather - Temperature 21 °C. Wind 1 kn at 248 °. Crosswind: 1 kn Headwind: 0 kn.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Takeoff distance 359 m 40 % of runway
100 %	Liftoff speed was 68 kn Target 70 kn
85.9 %	Runway alignment max 6.92 m 6.92 m left to 0.00 m left	0.66		6.92 m
86 %	Average g force 0.46 g 0.01 g min to max 1.00 g	1.00		0.01 g
100 %	Takeoff Bounce
Info	Average pitch angle 3.9 ° 3.3 ° min to max 4.6 °	4.6		3.6 °
Info	Average bank angle 0.2 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.8 °	0.3		0.8 °
Info	Battery Master On at 13:50:25
Info	Engine 1 Started at 13:50:25
Info	Beacon Lights Switched On at 13:50:25
Info	Navigation Lights Switched On at 13:50:25
Info	Strobe Lights Switched On at 13:50:25
Info	Landing Gear Down at 13:50:25
Info	Parking Brake On at 13:50:46
Info	Parking Brake Off at 13:51:08
0 %	Landing Lights at 13:51:03

Departure Climb 1

96.79 %

Departure climb to 50 ft agl from runway 16 EDTF Freiburg\/Breisgau.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
92.78 %	Heading variation -1.3 ° -1.6 ° min to max -0.8 °	-0.8		-1.6 °
100 %	Average speed 76 kn 68 kn min to max 80 kn	68		80 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 0.8 ° 0.0 ° min to max 1.3 °	0.8		0.2 °
86 %	Average g force 0.93 g 0.01 g min to max 1.04 g	0.01		0.91 g
Info	Average VSI 567 ft/m 373 ft/m min to max 745 ft/m	373		745 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 20 ft agl 0 ft agl min to max 54 ft agl	0		54 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle 6.8 ° 3.7 ° min to max 8.6 °	3.7		8.6 °

Departure Climb 2

89.26 %

Departure climb to 400 ft agl from 16 EDTF Freiburg\/Breisgau.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
59.88 %	Heading variation -2.2 ° -5.2 ° min to max -1.7 °	-1.7		-5.2 °
100 %	Average speed 80 kn 78 kn min to max 80 kn	80		80 kn
97.16 %	Average bank angle 1.4 ° 0.3 ° min to max 3.1 °	0.3		0.7 °
100 %	Average g force 0.93 g 0.84 g min to max 1.04 g	0.93		0.90 g
Info	Average VSI 949 ft/m 752 ft/m min to max 1,171 ft/m	752		925 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 122 ft agl 55 ft agl min to max 391 ft agl	55		391 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle 9.6 ° 8.7 ° min to max 10.6 °	8.7		8.7 °

Departure Climb 3

85.24 %

Departure climb to 1,000 ft agl from 16 EDTF Freiburg\/Breisgau.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
59.67 %	Heading variation -5.6 ° -6.4 ° min to max -3.8 °	-6.2		-3.8 °
100 %	Average speed 82 kn 80 kn min to max 83 kn	80		82 kn
66.55 %	Average bank angle 11.9 ° 2.9 ° min to max 14.7 °	2.9		12.8 °
100 %	Average g force 0.90 g 0.84 g min to max 0.94 g	0.87		0.90 g
100 %	Landing gear up
Info	Average VSI 866 ft/m 800 ft/m min to max 975 ft/m	900		975 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 497 ft agl 406 ft agl min to max 593 ft agl	406		593 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle 8.7 ° 8.2 ° min to max 9.5 °	8.6		9.5 °

Enroute Climb

100 %

Enroute climb started overhead Freiburg (Baden-Wuerttemberg, Germany). Climbing from 1,423 ft asl to 2,506 ft asl, an increase of 1,084 ft in 2 minutes and covering 3 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average speed 91 kn 80 kn min to max 107 kn	82		101 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 6.6 ° 0.1 ° min to max 15.8 °	12.1		3.8 °
100 %	Average g force 0.91 g 0.81 g min to max 1.01 g	0.90		0.88 g
Info	Average VSI 495 ft/m -191 ft/m min to max 1,197 ft/m	1,010		984 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 2,021 ft asl 1,423 ft asl min to max 2,506 ft asl	1,423		2,506 ft asl
Info	Average pitch angle 4.9 ° 0.8 ° min to max 9.7 °	9.6		5.6 °
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0
Info	Landing Gear Up at 13:53:55

Enroute Level

100 %

Enroute level cruise started 1 mile south of Umkirch (Baden-Wuerttemberg, Germany) and lasted 3 minutes, covering 6 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average altitude 2,634 ft asl 2,521 ft asl min to max 2,778 ft asl	2,521		2,672 ft asl
100 %	Average speed 122 kn 100 kn min to max 137 kn	100		122 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 8.1 ° 0.0 ° min to max 27.0 °	7.3		3.8 °
100 %	Average g force 0.92 g 0.80 g min to max 1.15 g	0.85		0.85 g
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0
Info	Average pitch angle 0.0 ° -3.2 ° min to max 5.3 °	5.3		-3.0 °

Enroute Descent

100 %

Enroute descent started overhead Botzingen (Baden-Wuerttemberg, Germany). Descent from 2,664 ft asl to 2,189 ft asl, a decrease of 475 ft in 1 minutes and covering 2 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average speed 119 kn 102 kn min to max 128 kn	123		102 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 9.5 ° 0.8 ° min to max 26.6 °	3.3		11.5 °
100 %	Average g force 0.93 g 0.82 g min to max 1.17 g	0.91		0.95 g
Info	Average VSI -443 ft/m -1,034 ft/m min to max 551 ft/m	-466		155 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 2,373 ft asl 2,161 ft asl min to max 2,664 ft asl	2,664		2,189 ft asl
Info	Average pitch angle -2.2 ° -4.8 ° min to max 2.5 °	-3.3		1.3 °
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0

Enroute Level 2

100 %

Enroute level cruise started 1 mile east of Botzingen (Baden-Wuerttemberg, Germany) and lasted less than 1 minute. , covering less than 1 nm.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average altitude 2,135 ft asl 2,068 ft asl min to max 2,207 ft asl	2,193		2,068 ft asl
100 %	Average speed 98 kn 93 kn min to max 102 kn	102		93 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 10.1 ° 0.8 ° min to max 17.6 °	9.4		3.9 °
100 %	Average g force 0.91 g 0.66 g min to max 1.05 g	0.92		0.93 g
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0
Info	Average pitch angle -0.4 ° -3.0 ° min to max 1.6 °	1.6		0.7 °
Info	Landing Gear Down at 13:58:48

Arrival

100 %

Arrival started 1 mile east of Botzingen (Baden-Wuerttemberg, Germany).

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Average speed 83 kn 73 kn min to max 92 kn	92		73 kn
100 %	Average bank angle 4.5 ° 0.1 ° min to max 14.3 °	4.0		0.1 °
100 %	Average g force 0.91 g 0.84 g min to max 1.03 g	0.97		0.94 g
Info	Average VSI -477 ft/m -897 ft/m min to max -169 ft/m	-180		-897 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 1,694 ft asl 1,197 ft asl min to max 2,065 ft asl	2,065		1,197 ft asl
Info	Average pitch angle -0.4 ° -3.3 ° min to max 2.1 °	1.1		-3.1 °
Info	Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0	0		0
Info	Flaps Position 3 at 14:00:24

Arrival Final 1

89.1 %

Approaching runway 16 at EDTF Freiburg\/Breisgau from 1 nm to 0 nm. Descent from 385 ft agl to 10 ft agl. A decrease of 375 ft in 23 seconds.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
50.32 %	Approach angle 2.1 ° 1.1 ° min to max 5.1 ° Target 3.0 °	5.1		1.1 °
100 %	Average speed 71 kn 66 kn min to max 76 kn	73		66 kn
95.2 %	Heading variation 0.5 ° 0.4 ° min to max 0.6 °	0.6		0.4 °
100 %	Average bank angle 0.5 ° 0.0 ° min to max 2.2 °	0.1		0.7 °
100 %	Average g force 0.95 g 0.82 g min to max 1.06 g	0.89		0.89 g
Info	Average VSI -786 ft/m -1,085 ft/m min to max -328 ft/m	-896		-328 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 66 ft agl 10 ft agl min to max 385 ft agl	385		10 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle -1.0 ° -4.8 ° min to max 2.6 °	-3.2		2.6 °

Arrival Landing

100 %

Landing on runway 16 at EDTF Freiburg\/Breisgau, runway length 892 m. Good threshold height. Threshold speed was slightly below target at 66 kn.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Threshold speed was slightly below target at 66 kn. Target 70 kn
100 %	Target 48 ft agl
100 %	Landing and flare profile
100 %	Heading variation 0.3 ° 0.3 ° min to max 0.4 °	0.4		0.3 °
100 %	Average bank angle 0.4 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.7 °	0.7		0.4 °
100 %	Average g force 0.91 g 0.85 g min to max 1.01 g	0.90		0.86 g
Info	Average speed 62 kn 58 kn min to max 66 kn	66		58 kn
Info	Average VSI -260 ft/m -325 ft/m min to max -189 ft/m	-325		-189 ft/m
Info	Average altitude 11 ft agl 4 ft agl min to max 19 ft agl	19		4 ft agl
Info	Average pitch angle 3.0 ° 2.4 ° min to max 4.0 °	2.6		2.8 °

Arrival Touchdown

98.67 %

Touchdown distance was good at 140 m. Touchdown speed at 58 kn was a little fast. Touchdown rate was good at -189 ft/m. Runway touchdown position was slightly misaligned by 3.7 m from centreline. Local weather - Temperature 22 °C. Wind 1 kn at 41 °. Crosswind: 1 kn Headwind: 0 kn.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
96.93 %	Touchdown VSI was -189 ft/m.
100 %	Touchdown distance was 140 m Target 450 m
100 %	Speed at touchdown 58 kn Target 55 kn
97.64 %	Runway alignment max 3.69 m 3.50 m left	3.69		3.26 m
100 %	Average bank angle 0.3 ° 0.1 ° min to max 0.4 °	0.4		0.1 °
95.71 %	Average g force 0.74 g 0.35 g min to max 0.97 g	0.86		0.35 g
100 %	Landing Bounce
Info	Average speed 58 kn 57 kn min to max 58 kn	58		57 kn
Info	Average pitch angle 4.0 ° 2.8 ° min to max 5.8 °	2.8		5.8 °

Arrival Rollout

93.56 %

Total landing distance 527 m, 59 % of runway. Runway rollout alignment was very good.

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
100 %	Landing distance 527 m 59 % of runway.
87.53 %	Runway alignment max 8.52 m 6.47 m left to 2.05 m right	3.24		4.26 m
91.71 %	Average g force 0.45 g 0.21 g min to max 0.84 g	0.32		0.77 g
Info	Average speed 60 kn 37 kn min to max 66 kn	66		37 kn
Info	Average pitch angle 3.0 ° 1.6 ° min to max 5.9 °	5.9		2.7 °
Info	Average bank angle 0.3 ° 0.0 ° min to max 1.5 °	0.1		0.4 °

Runway Exit

Exiting runway, average speed 11 kn

Score	Description	Start	Profile	End
Info	Average speed 23 kn 15 kn min to max 30 kn	30		15 kn
Info	Average pitch angle 3.1 ° 3.0 ° min to max 3.4 °	3.4		3.0 °
Info	Average bank angle 0.2 ° 0.2 ° min to max 0.2 °	0.2		0.2 °
Info	Average g force 0.86 g 0.81 g min to max 0.90 g	0.81		0.86 g

Takeoff on runway 16 at EDTF Freiburg\/Breisgau in the Piper PA-24-250 Comanche

90.52 %

90.78 %

Takeoff Roll

Takeoff Distance

100 %

Roll distance of 359 m using 40.31 % of runway

Liftoff Speed

100 %

Liftoff speed was 68 kn - Target 70 kn

Alignment

85.9 %

6.92 m left to 0.00 m left

Bounce

100 %

No Bounce Detected

Strobe Lights

100 %

Switched On

Landing Lights

0 %

Switched On

86 %

IAS kt

Info

Bank °

Info

Pitch °

Info

96.79 %

Climb 1

Departure climb to 50 ft agl from runway 16 EDTF Freiburg\/Breisgau.

Alignment

92.78 %

IAS kt

100 %

Bank °

100 %

86 %

Pitch °

Info

Climb Rate fpm

Info

89.26 %

Climb 2

Departure climb to 400 ft agl from 16 EDTF Freiburg\/Breisgau.

Alignment

59.88 %

IAS kt

100 %

Bank °

97.16 %

100 %

Pitch °

Info

Climb Rate fpm

Info

85.24 %

Climb 3

Departure climb to 1,000 ft agl from 16 EDTF Freiburg\/Breisgau.

Alignment

59.67 %

IAS kt

100 %

Bank °

66.55 %

100 %

Pitch °

Info

Climb Rate fpm

Info

Landing on runway 16 at EDTF Freiburg\/Breisgau in the Piper PA-24-250 Comanche

Landing Score 95.33 %

Landing Summary

Overall, your aircraft landing score of 95.3% is a strong result, demonstrating your skill and proficiency as a pilot.

In the Approach Phase, while the descent path was slightly above the glideslope limit and the speed was slightly below target, these areas can be improved with practice and attention to detail. Focus on maintaining a stable descent path and monitoring your speed closely to stay within the target range.

During the Landing Phase, you excelled in threshold height and landing flare, showcasing your ability to handle the critical moments before touchdown with precision. However, the landing heading was noted as poor, indicating the need for adjustments to ensure a straight and aligned touchdown.

In the Touchdown Phase, your touchdown rate was good despite the speed being slightly above target. Work on fine-tuning your approach speed to achieve a smoother touchdown. The touchdown distance inside the touchdown zone is commendable, showing good accuracy in your touchdown point. Additionally, the runway touchdown position being 3.7 m from the centreline suggests room for improvement in maintaining a more centered landing.

Lastly, in the Rollout Phase, the runway alignment of 6.5 m from the centreline highlights the importance of maintaining control and alignment during the rollout process. Focus on refining your runway tracking to ensure a straight and steady rollout.

Overall, while there are areas for improvement, your performance demonstrates strong capabilities in various aspects of the landing process. Keep practicing and fine-tuning your skills to continue improving your landing proficiency. Your dedication and commitment to excellence in aviation are evident, and with continued effort, you will undoubtedly achieve even higher scores in future landings. Keep up the great work!

89.1 %

Final 1

Approaching runway 16 at EDTF Freiburg\/Breisgau from 1 nm to 0 nm. Descent from 385 ft agl to 10 ft agl. A decrease of 375 ft in 23 seconds.

Glideslope

50.32 %

Poor descent path above glideslope limit

Heading

95.2 %

Excellent heading alignment

Glideslope °

50.32 %

IAS kt