The flight in the Airbus A320 from LIMC Milan Malpensa International Airport to LFOB Paris-Beauvais Airport was smooth and efficient.
Taxiing from the parking to the runway at Milan Malpensa took 9 minutes and covered 2 nm. The departure roll from runway 35L saw a takeoff distance of 1,971m, with a liftoff speed of 155 knots. The local weather at departure included a temperature of 14°C with a light 2 knot wind at 240° providing minimal crosswind.
The enroute climb started over the airport in Ferno, Italy, climbing from 1,439 ft asl to 34,334 ft asl in 18 minutes and covering 91 nm. The level cruise then began over Saint-Gingolph, France, and lasted 27 minutes, covering 195 nm. The descent started over Mancy, France, descending from 34,357 ft asl to 3,091 ft asl in 20 minutes and covering 93 nm. Another brief level cruise followed over Campeaux, France, lasting 4 minutes and covering 11 nm.
The landing on runway 12 at Paris-Beauvais Airport saw a touchdown 307 m from the threshold at a speed of 135 knots with a VSI of -457 ft/m. The total landing distance was 1,065m, utilizing 45% of the runway length. The local weather at landing included a temperature of 11°C with a light 1 knot wind at 241°, offering minimal crosswind.
Taxiing back to the parking from the runway at Paris-Beauvais took 7 minutes and covered less than 1 nm. The total flight distance was 400 nm, taking 96 minutes in total, and consuming 3,577 kg of fuel. Overall, the flight was executed efficiently and safely, with smooth transitions during all phases of the journey.
Replay this flight in 3D — the full flight path over the terrain with every stage, event and score along the route.
Taxiing from the parking to the runway took 9 minutes and covered 2 nm.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 77.33 % |
Average speed 15 kn 0 kn min to max 28 kn |
2 | 13 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average speed turning corners 9 kn max 9 kn |
0 | 0 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.00 g 0.99 g min to max 1.01 g |
1.00 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle -0.2 ° -1.0 ° min to max 0.4 ° |
0.4 | 0.0 ° | |
| Info |
Average bank angle 0.1 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.4 ° |
0.1 | 0.1 ° | |
| Info |
Battery Master On at 19:39:15 |
|||
| Info |
Engine 2 Started at 19:39:15 |
|||
| Info |
Beacon Lights Switched On at 19:39:15 |
|||
| Info |
Navigation Lights Switched On at 19:39:15 |
|||
| Info |
Landing Gear Down at 19:39:15 |
|||
| Info |
Parking Brake On at 19:40:23 |
|||
| Info |
Engine 1 Started at 19:40:28 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 2 at 19:41:10 |
|||
| Info |
Taxi Lights Switched On at 19:43:06 |
|||
| Info |
Parking Brake Off at 19:43:10 |
Entering runway 35L at LIMC Milan Malpensa International Airport, Average speed was 8 kn.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| Info |
Average speed 9 kn 8 kn min to max 12 kn |
12 | 8 kn | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 0.1 ° -0.4 ° min to max 0.2 ° |
-0.1 | 0.0 ° | |
| Info |
Average bank angle 0.1 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.2 ° |
0.1 | 0.1 ° | |
| Info |
Average g force 1.00 g 1.00 g min to max 1.01 g |
1.00 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Strobe Lights Switched On at 19:48:09 |
|||
| Info |
Landing Lights Switched On at 19:48:11 |
Departure roll runway 35L at LIMC Milan Malpensa International Airport. Takeoff distance 1,971 m 56 % of runway. Liftoff speed was 155 kn. Local weather - Temperature 14 °C. Wind 2 kn at 240 °. Crosswind: 1 kn Headwind: 0 kn.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Takeoff distance 1,971 m 56 % of runway |
|||
| 100 % |
Liftoff speed was 155 kn Target 154 kn |
|||
| 98.61 % |
Runway alignment max 3.43 m 3.43 m left to 0.00 m left |
2.28 | 2.60 m | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.00 g 0.96 g min to max 1.04 g |
1.00 | 1.00 g | |
| 100 % |
Takeoff Bounce |
|||
| Info |
Average pitch angle 0.9 ° -0.1 ° min to max 9.8 ° |
0.1 | 9.8 ° | |
| Info |
Average bank angle 0.1 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.3 ° |
0.1 | 0.2 ° |
Departure climb to 50 ft agl from runway 35L LIMC Milan Malpensa International Airport.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Heading variation -0.1 ° -0.1 ° min to max -0.1 ° |
-0.1 | -0.1 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 156 kn 155 kn min to max 156 kn |
155 | 156 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.3 ° 0.2 ° min to max 0.3 ° |
0.2 | 0.3 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.18 g 1.00 g min to max 1.25 g |
1.00 | 1.22 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI 614 ft/m 242 ft/m min to max 1,291 ft/m |
242 | 1,291 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 15 ft agl 0 ft agl min to max 51 ft agl |
0 | 51 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 14.3 ° 10.0 ° min to max 17.7 ° |
10.0 | 17.7 ° |
Departure climb to 400 ft agl from 35L LIMC Milan Malpensa International Airport.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Heading variation -0.0 ° -0.1 ° min to max -0.0 ° |
-0.1 | -0.0 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 155 kn 149 kn min to max 156 kn |
156 | 149 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.1 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.3 ° |
0.3 | 0.1 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.13 g 0.89 g min to max 1.21 g |
1.21 | 0.93 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI 1,871 ft/m 1,315 ft/m min to max 2,780 ft/m |
1,315 | 2,531 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 122 ft agl 52 ft agl min to max 401 ft agl |
52 | 401 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 18.4 ° 17.7 ° min to max 19.5 ° |
17.8 | 18.1 ° | |
| Info |
Taxi Lights Switched Off at 19:50:08 |
|||
| Info |
Landing Gear Up at 19:50:08 |
Departure climb to 1,000 ft agl from 35L LIMC Milan Malpensa International Airport.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Heading variation -0.3 ° -0.9 ° min to max -0.0 ° |
-0.0 | -0.9 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 148 kn 147 kn min to max 150 kn |
148 | 150 kn | |
| 35.26 % |
Average bank angle 16.7 ° 3.9 ° min to max 26.6 ° |
3.9 | 24.8 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 0.90 g 0.88 g min to max 0.94 g |
0.93 | 0.94 g | |
| 100 % |
Landing gear up |
|||
| Info |
Average VSI 1,889 ft/m 1,172 ft/m min to max 2,402 ft/m |
2,402 | 1,172 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 594 ft agl 481 ft agl min to max 682 ft agl |
481 | 682 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 15.4 ° 12.6 ° min to max 17.9 ° |
17.9 | 12.6 ° |
Enroute climb started overhead LIMC Milan Malpensa International Airport Ferno (VA) (Lombardia, Italy). Climbing from 1,439 ft asl to 34,334 ft asl, an increase of 32,895 ft in 18 minutes and covering 91 nm.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Average speed 245 kn 151 kn min to max 294 kn |
151 | 264 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 10.4 ° 0.0 ° min to max 25.7 ° |
21.1 | 0.0 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.02 g 0.91 g min to max 1.09 g |
1.00 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI 1,828 ft/m 213 ft/m min to max 3,343 ft/m |
985 | 213 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 15,413 ft asl 1,439 ft asl min to max 34,334 ft asl |
1,439 | 34,334 ft asl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 7.5 ° 2.8 ° min to max 14.8 ° |
12.3 | 3.2 ° | |
| Info |
Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0 |
0 | 0 | |
| Info |
Flaps Position 1 at 19:51:45 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Fully Retracted at 19:51:54 |
|||
| Info |
Landing Lights Switched Off at 19:54:04 |
Enroute level cruise started 2 miles south west of Saint-Gingolph (Auvergne-Rhone-Alpes, France) and lasted 27 minutes, covering 195 nm.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Average altitude 34,362 ft asl 34,355 ft asl min to max 34,369 ft asl |
34,357 | 34,364 ft asl | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 265 kn 262 kn min to max 267 kn |
266 | 265 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 5.5 ° 0.0 ° min to max 22.4 ° |
0.0 | 22.3 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.01 g 0.94 g min to max 1.08 g |
0.99 | 0.94 g | |
| Info |
Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0 |
0 | 0 | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 2.9 ° 2.0 ° min to max 3.0 ° |
2.9 | 2.0 ° |
Enroute descent started overhead Mancy (Grand Est, France). Descent from 34,357 ft asl to 3,091 ft asl, a decrease of 31,267 ft in 20 minutes and covering 93 nm.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Average speed 259 kn 188 kn min to max 291 kn |
264 | 188 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 14.1 ° 0.0 ° min to max 26.6 ° |
22.3 | 23.2 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.04 g 0.82 g min to max 1.19 g |
0.89 | 1.08 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI -1,817 ft/m -4,892 ft/m min to max 22 ft/m |
-298 | -4 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 16,917 ft asl 3,087 ft asl min to max 34,357 ft asl |
34,357 | 3,091 ft asl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 0.6 ° -3.6 ° min to max 6.8 ° |
1.4 | 6.7 ° | |
| Info |
Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0 |
0 | 0 | |
| Info |
Landing Lights Switched On at 20:44:39 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 1 at 20:50:46 |
Enroute level cruise started 2 miles south of Campeaux (Hauts-de-France, France) and lasted 4 minutes, covering 11 nm.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 94.62 % |
Average altitude 2,819 ft asl 2,077 ft asl min to max 3,103 ft asl |
3,091 | 2,077 ft asl | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 170 kn 137 kn min to max 189 kn |
188 | 138 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 10.0 ° 0.0 ° min to max 23.6 ° |
23.2 | 0.0 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.03 g 0.96 g min to max 1.08 g |
1.08 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0 |
0 | 0 | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 5.2 ° 2.6 ° min to max 6.7 ° |
6.6 | 3.0 ° | |
| Info |
Flaps Position 2 at 20:57:14 |
|||
| Info |
Landing Gear Down at 20:57:20 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 3 at 20:57:21 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 4 at 20:57:57 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 5 at 20:58:08 |
Arrival started 2 miles south of Campeaux (Hauts-de-France, France).
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Average speed 137 kn 137 kn min to max 138 kn |
138 | 138 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.0 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.0 ° |
0.0 | 0.0 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.00 g 1.00 g min to max 1.00 g |
1.00 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI -749 ft/m -757 ft/m min to max -742 ft/m |
-750 | -748 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 1,852 ft asl 1,640 ft asl min to max 2,064 ft asl |
2,064 | 1,640 ft asl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 2.9 ° 2.8 ° min to max 3.0 ° |
3.0 | 2.9 ° | |
| Info |
Turn coordination 0 0 min to max 0 |
0 | 0 | |
| Info |
Taxi Lights Switched On at 20:59:14 |
Approaching runway 12 at LFOB Paris-Beauvais Airport from 4 nm to 3 nm. Descent from 1,289 ft agl to 990 ft agl. A decrease of 299 ft in 24 seconds.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Approach angle 3.1 ° 3.0 ° min to max 3.1 ° Target 3.0 ° |
3.0 | 3.1 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 137 kn 137 kn min to max 138 kn |
138 | 137 kn | |
| 100 % |
Heading variation -0.1 ° -0.1 ° min to max -0.0 ° |
-0.1 | -0.0 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.0 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.0 ° |
0.0 | 0.0 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.00 g 1.00 g min to max 1.00 g |
1.00 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI -747 ft/m -755 ft/m min to max -741 ft/m |
-751 | -746 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 1,139 ft agl 990 ft agl min to max 1,289 ft agl |
1,289 | 990 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 2.9 ° 2.9 ° min to max 2.9 ° |
2.9 | 2.9 ° |
Approaching runway 12 at LFOB Paris-Beauvais Airport from 3 nm to 2 nm. Descent from 978 ft agl to 669 ft agl. A decrease of 309 ft in 24 seconds.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Approach angle 3.1 ° 3.1 ° min to max 3.1 ° Target 3.0 ° |
3.1 | 3.1 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 137 kn 137 kn min to max 138 kn |
137 | 137 kn | |
| 100 % |
Heading variation -0.0 ° -0.0 ° min to max -0.0 ° |
-0.0 | -0.0 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.0 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.0 ° |
0.0 | 0.0 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.00 g 1.00 g min to max 1.00 g |
1.00 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI -742 ft/m -753 ft/m min to max -728 ft/m |
-744 | -753 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 820 ft agl 669 ft agl min to max 978 ft agl |
978 | 669 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 2.9 ° 2.8 ° min to max 3.0 ° |
2.9 | 2.9 ° |
Approaching runway 12 at LFOB Paris-Beauvais Airport from 2 nm to 1 nm. Descent from 657 ft agl to 353 ft agl. A decrease of 304 ft in 24 seconds.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Approach angle 3.1 ° 3.1 ° min to max 3.2 ° Target 3.0 ° |
3.1 | 3.2 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 137 kn 137 kn min to max 138 kn |
137 | 137 kn | |
| 100 % |
Heading variation -0.0 ° -0.0 ° min to max -0.0 ° |
-0.0 | -0.0 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.2 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.9 ° |
0.0 | 0.9 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.00 g 1.00 g min to max 1.00 g |
1.00 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI -731 ft/m -752 ft/m min to max -704 ft/m |
-752 | -704 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 501 ft agl 353 ft agl min to max 657 ft agl |
657 | 353 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 3.0 ° 2.9 ° min to max 3.0 ° |
2.9 | 3.0 ° |
Approaching runway 12 at LFOB Paris-Beauvais Airport from 1 nm to 0 nm. Descent from 341 ft agl to 61 ft agl. A decrease of 280 ft in 20 seconds.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Approach angle 3.2 ° 3.1 ° min to max 3.4 ° Target 3.0 ° |
3.2 | 3.1 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average speed 137 kn 137 kn min to max 138 kn |
137 | 137 kn | |
| 100 % |
Heading variation 0.1 ° -0.0 ° min to max 0.1 ° |
-0.0 | 0.1 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.7 ° 0.0 ° min to max 1.3 ° |
0.8 | 0.3 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.01 g 0.98 g min to max 1.04 g |
1.00 | 1.04 g | |
| Info |
Average VSI -850 ft/m -896 ft/m min to max -703 ft/m |
-703 | -823 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 123 ft agl 61 ft agl min to max 341 ft agl |
341 | 61 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 2.7 ° 2.1 ° min to max 3.3 ° |
3.0 | 3.3 ° |
Landing on runway 12 at LFOB Paris-Beauvais Airport, runway length 2,379 m. Good threshold height. Threshold speed was good at 137 kn.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Threshold speed was good at 137 kn. Target 135 kn |
|||
| 100 % |
Target 50 ft agl |
|||
| 72.45 % |
Landing and flare profile |
|||
| 100 % |
Heading variation 0.1 ° 0.1 ° min to max 0.1 ° |
0.1 | 0.1 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.3 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.9 ° |
0.2 | 0.9 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.04 g 1.03 g min to max 1.06 g |
1.04 | 1.03 g | |
| Info |
Average speed 137 kn 135 kn min to max 137 kn |
137 | 135 kn | |
| Info |
Average VSI -641 ft/m -821 ft/m min to max -457 ft/m |
-821 | -457 ft/m | |
| Info |
Average altitude 23 ft agl 5 ft agl min to max 46 ft agl |
46 | 5 ft agl | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 3.9 ° 3.3 ° min to max 4.6 ° |
3.3 | 4.6 ° |
Touchdown distance was good at 307 m. Touchdown speed at 135 kn was a little fast. Touchdown rate was hard at -457 ft/m. Runway touchdown position was slightly misaligned by 4.9 m from centreline. Local weather - Temperature 11 °C. Wind 1 kn at 241 °. Crosswind: 1 kn Tailwind: 1 kn.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 87.7 % |
Touchdown VSI was -457 ft/m. |
|||
| 100 % |
Touchdown distance was 307 m Target 457 m |
|||
| 100 % |
Speed at touchdown 135 kn Target 132 kn |
|||
| 93.37 % |
Runway alignment max 4.87 m 4.73 m left |
4.87 | 4.58 m | |
| 100 % |
Average bank angle 0.7 ° 0.5 ° min to max 0.9 ° |
0.9 | 0.8 ° | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.26 g 1.03 g min to max 1.39 g |
1.03 | 1.25 g | |
| 100 % |
Landing Bounce |
|||
| Info |
Average speed 134 kn 133 kn min to max 135 kn |
135 | 133 kn | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 4.7 ° 4.6 ° min to max 5.0 ° |
4.6 | 5.0 ° |
Total landing distance 1,065 m, 45 % of runway. Runway rollout alignment was very good.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 100 % |
Landing distance 1,065 m 45 % of runway. |
|||
| 94.63 % |
Runway alignment max 7.12 m 4.52 m left to 2.60 m right |
4.52 | 2.85 m | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.01 g 0.92 g min to max 1.18 g |
1.18 | 0.99 g | |
| Info |
Average speed 124 kn 73 kn min to max 133 kn |
133 | 73 kn | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 5.0 ° -0.3 ° min to max 6.0 ° |
5.2 | -0.3 ° | |
| Info |
Average bank angle 1.2 ° 0.0 ° min to max 2.0 ° |
0.9 | 0.1 ° |
Exiting runway, average speed 10 kn
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| Info |
Average speed 11 kn 3 kn min to max 67 kn |
67 | 18 kn | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle -0.0 ° -0.5 ° min to max 0.3 ° |
-0.2 | -0.1 ° | |
| Info |
Average bank angle 0.2 ° 0.0 ° min to max 0.4 ° |
0.1 | 0.0 ° | |
| Info |
Average g force 1.00 g 0.99 g min to max 1.03 g |
1.01 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Flaps Position 4 at 21:01:50 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 3 at 21:01:53 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 2 at 21:02:01 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Position 1 at 21:02:03 |
|||
| Info |
Flaps Fully Retracted at 21:02:12 |
|||
| Info |
Landing Lights Switched Off at 21:02:30 |
Taxiing to the parking from the runway took 7 minutes and covered less than 1 nm.
| Score | Description | Start | Profile | End |
| 57.33 % |
Average speed 16 kn 2 kn min to max 31 kn |
19 | 2 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average speed turning corners 4 kn max 5 kn |
0 | 0 kn | |
| 100 % |
Average g force 1.00 g 0.98 g min to max 1.01 g |
1.00 | 1.00 g | |
| Info |
Average pitch angle 0.1 ° -2.1 ° min to max 1.2 ° |
-0.1 | -0.1 ° | |
| Info |
Average bank angle 0.4 ° 0.0 ° min to max 1.5 ° |
0.2 | 0.0 ° | |
| Info |
Taxi Lights Switched Off at 21:09:54 |
First off, congratulations on achieving an impressive aircraft landing score of 96.7%! This is a testament to your skill and precision as a pilot.
Let's break down the different phases of the landing and analyze your performance. In the Approach Phase, you did an excellent job with glideslope alignment, which is crucial for setting up a smooth and controlled descent towards the runway. This indicates that you have a good understanding of the aircraft's positioning in relation to the desired flight path.
Moving on to the Landing Phase, it's great to see that you had a good threshold height and executed a proper landing flare. This shows that you were able to gauge the altitude and timing of the flare correctly, resulting in a smooth touchdown on the runway.
In the Touchdown Phase, while the touchdown rate was noted to be very hard, it's important to take note of this and aim for a softer touchdown in future landings. Additionally, having the speed a little above target is understandable, but try to work on maintaining the desired speed for a smoother touchdown. The fact that the touchdown distance was within the touchdown zone is a positive point, as this indicates that you were able to accurately judge the landing point on the runway. However, the runway touchdown position being 4.9 meters from the centerline could be improved upon by aiming for a more precise alignment with the runway centerline.
Finally, in the Rollout Phase, having a runway alignment of 4.5 meters from the centerline is a good effort, but there is room for improvement in terms of achieving a more centered alignment for better control and stability during the rollout phase.
Overall, your landing performance was commendable, with strong points in glideslope alignment, threshold height, landing flare execution, and rollout alignment. By focusing on areas such as touchdown rate, touchdown speed, and runway alignment, you can further enhance your skills and strive for even higher landing scores in the future. Keep up the great work and continue refining your techniques to become an even more proficient pilot.
Drag to zoom · double-click to reset · hover for values